91865 Overseas Hwy - Image 1
1 of 15

$5,950,000

91865 Overseas Hwy

Tavernier, FL 33070•Monroe County
Mixed UseFor SaleActive

Property Highlights

0 / 0

Beds / Baths

10,150

Square Feet

0.49

Acres

1936

Year Built

About This Property

Presenting an unparalleled new investment opportunity on the Overseas Highway at Mile Marker 98 in Tavernier FL Keys, featuring 143 feet of direct frontage and offering a truly turn-key cash flow property. This robust mixed-use portfolio includes five fully renovated commercial buildings and ten residential units secured by long-term leases, ensuring immediate revenue stability. The entire property has undergone a comprehensive, full gut-out rehabilitation, showcasing brand new 2024 metal roofs, impact windows and doors, new plumbing, electrical systems, stucco, paint, and high-end pavers, resulting in an unmatched, maintenance-light asset. With a Pro Forma NOI of $495,250, and the owner guaranteeing 100% occupancy at closing, this is a meticulously modernized income machine ready for immediate acquisition by the discerning investor.

Property Details

Year Built1936
Living Area10,150 sqft
Lot Size0.49 acres

Listing Information

MLS IDA11924601
MLS NameMiamiAssociationOfRealtors
Sale TypeFor Sale
Days on Market96 days
Last UpdatedDec 15, 2025
Price ChangedDec 15, 2025

Virtual Tour

Take a virtual walk through this property from the comfort of your home.

View Virtual Tour

Request Information

Quick Stats

Property Type:Mixed Use
Status:Active
Listed:N/A